Whitfield Pellet Stove: A Comprehensive Product Specification Review
  • Home
  • Stove

Whitfield Pellet Stove: A Comprehensive Product Specification Review

Pellet stoves have emerged as an excellent option for those wanting to add clean and affordable wood heat to their home. The simplicity and convenience of pellet stoves have made them a favorite choice for those needing both primary heating sources in their homes and supplemental heat in vacation homes and offices. With a lot of options on the market, however, it can be hard to choose the right pellet stove. In this article, we will take a look at the Whitfield brand and help you decide if a Whitfield pellet stove might be the right choice. 

To give a better look at some of the available options in a Whitfield pellet stove, we dug deep on one particular model—the Advantage II-T. We broke down a number of the different specs available on the Whitfield Advantage II-T and also compared it with a few other leading pellet stoves on the market. Special attention was paid to the heating capability, pellet capacity, efficiency, and features in each pellet stove. We also considered the price, availability, and offered a few pros and cons for each stove to give you a quick reference.

In the end, we also chose one overall top selection from this list to help you decide if a Whitfield pellet stove might fit your needs.

What is the Whitfield Advantage II-T Pellet Stove?

The Whitfield Advantage II-T pellet stove is one of the most popular models from the Whitfield brand. In the simplest terms, it is a heating unit that burns small pellets of compressed wood. These pellets are sold in 50-pound bags and then filled into a hopper at the top of the stove. A handful of the pellets are placed into a burning tray in the front portion of the stove, covered with gel lighter fluid, and ignited. 

Once this initial flame has caught on and is burning consistently, the front aspect of the stove is closed, creating a closed environment in which the flame continues to burn. A control panel on the side of the Whitfield pellet stove allows the user to control the fan speed, auger speed, and the rate at which pellets will feed from the hopper down into the flame. Once the desired settings are selected, the pellet stove will create a consistent flame indefinitely as long as the hopper is refilled and the unit has consistent power. 

Whitfield Pellet Stove Product Specs 

The Whitfield Advantage II-T is a high-quality pellet stove with a number of premium features. This stove has a generous 70-pound capacity for pellets in the hopper and allows for 54 hours of continuous burn time on a low setting without needing to refill. It can be connected to a wall-mounted thermostat to automatically increase or decrease heat settings depending on ambient room temperature.

It's a highly efficient system and includes Whitfield's patented UltraGrate flame basket. This is a channeled portion that allows for nearly 100% combustion of all pellets without the need for stoking or manual adjustment. It has an exceptional 79-81% efficiency rating, meaning that the pellets burn so completely that there is almost no visible smoke released from the external exhaust vent.

The control panel boasts large, easy-to-read LEDs and five different heat settings. It's easy to dial in the perfect amount of comfort from this Whitfield pellet stove and it could be an ideal choice as a primary heat source for a home, office or vacation property. This Whitfield pellet stove would be an ideal choice as the primary heat source for a seasonal residence or a simple and easily installed unit for a little added warmth in a full-time home.

Pricing  

Pricing for pellet stoves can vary widely depending on the make, model, features, and even the time of year in which you are shopping. High quality refurbished and used pellet stoves often sell for around $700, but you can find a new Whitfield pellet stove for around $1500. 

How it Compares

We picked a few similar products available on the market to see how they compare.     

  • Harman P68 Pellet Stove
  • Castle 12327 Serenity Wood Pellet Stove
  • Pleasant Hearth Large 50000 BTU's Pellet Stove
Whitfield Advantage II-T Pellet Stove

Price

Whitfield's Advantage II-T currently sells from various retailers for around $700.

Quality

Description

Rating

Heating Ability 

This has an impressive 38,000 BTU rating.

Capacity

This stove can house up to 70 pounds of pellets in the hopper at a time

Efficiency 

With an efficiency rating of 79 to 81 percent, this is a very efficient stove.

Features

This Whitfield pellet stove is very intuitive and user-friendly.

Pros

  • Excellent features
  • User-friendly
  • Lots of heating capacity
  • Very efficient

Cons

  • Whitfield was sold in 1999 and are no longer in production
Harman P68 Pellet Stove

Harman's P68 pellet stove is a big, powerful stove with a host of top-end features. It has a hopper capacity of 76 pounds and a maximum heat rating of 71,200 BTU, so this thing can heat large spaces for a long time. It, in fact, has a listed heating space capacity of 3,900 square feet. With those specs, it's the most powerful of all the pellet stoves in the P line from Harman.

Despite the massive heating power, this is also a very efficient stove. It maximizes clean fuel burning by using a progressive accordion style exhaust. This helps keep the ignited pellets well fanned while also lifting most particulate up and out of the living space. It also stays considerably cleaner than some competing stoves with Harman's proprietary an system on glass surfaces.

The P68's controls allow the user to dial in temperatures within one degree of accuracy. These top features coupled with super easy installing make this a winning choice for those needing a lot of heating power with an elegant design. It could be a perfect choice for either a primary heat source in a home or someone looking for a little extra warmth with premium quality features and aesthetics.

Price

This stove currently retails new for around $4,300.

Quality

Description

Rating

Heating Ability 

The P68 could feasibly be the only heat source in a small house or a cabin.

Capacity

An extra-large 76-pound hopper gives excellent capacity.

Efficiency 

The accordion vent system gives ample efficiency

Features

This stove has very easy controls and is highly programmable. 

Pros

  • Sleek design
  • High capacity
  • Excellent heating power
  • Very efficient

Cons

  • Bigger physical frame
  • Higher priced

Castle Pellet Stoves 12327 Serenity Wood Pellet Stove with Smart Controller, 18-1/4"W x 34" H x 23-3/4"D, Black
  • Reinvent the way you heat your home with Castle's Serenity wood pellet stove and new Smart Controller
  • The Smart Controller allows you to choose manual, thermostat, and weekly operational modes to heat your home on your schedule, Along with calendar and time based heating options, you can also set a local thermostat or manually set it on one of five burn levels

Castle's 12327 Serenity pellet stove is an excellent choice for someone who needs reliable heat at an affordable price. This doesn't have all of the power of features of a Whitfield pellet stove or a Harman, but it could be a great choice to add extra heat to a cool spot in the house or the lake house. It has a 40-pound hopper capacity and a maximum heating capacity of 22,226 BTUs. This will heat an area of around 1,500 square feet. While that may seem like a weakness, it could be an ideal choice for smaller spaces.

The Serenity has a number of user-friendly features including manual, thermostat, and weekly settings. It also has five different heat level settings and easy access to the burn chamber for quick cleaning. With around 70% thermal efficiency it will also keep your fuel costs low while enjoying a high level of warm comfort.

The Castle 12327 Serenity would be an ideal heat source for someone that needs a little extra heat but doesn't need to warm the entire house. This is a high quality yet an affordable option that will install easily and provide some nice ambiance as well.

Price

This stove currently retails via amazon.com for around $1,200.

Quality

Description

Rating

Heating Ability 

This is on the lower end of the heating ability with around 1,500 square feet. 

Capacity

Serenity has a comparatively small capacity at 40 pounds.

Efficiency 

Lower power and capacity help the efficiency on this stove. 

Features

This stove is highly programmable and functional.

Pros

  • Excellent value
  • Highly programmable
  • Good efficiency
  • Small footprint

Cons

  • Lower heating power
  • Smaller pellet capacity

Pleasant Hearth 35,000 BTU Medium Pellet Stove
  • Heating an area up to 1750 square feet
  • 35000 BTU, 40-pound hopper, burn time: 12-24 hours

Pleasant Hearth offers the largest and most powerful pellet stove on our list. Compared with the Whitfield pellet stove, this has considerably more power and capacity. At 50000 BTU, this stove has the power to heat a space of over 2,000 square feet. A massive hopper with a capacity of over 80-pounds is the engine that drives this beast.

It's not only big, however, but it's also efficient. The Pleasant Hearth has been rate at over 80% efficiency so you'll get long-lasting heat and excellent value from your fuel investment. Another great thing about this pellet stove is that it's very easy to use. One large control knob allows the user to set a desired temperature range and let the stove do the rest. It has an auto-ignition feature that makes startup a snap, and the ceramic glass window allows for easy cleaning and a pleasant view.

This stove could be an excellent choice for someone seeking a primary heat source for their home and would like an alternative to a traditional furnace, electric baseboard heating or natural gas.

Price

The Pleasant Hearth Large pellet stove currently retails on amazon.com for around $1,300.

Quality

Description

Rating

Heating Ability 

This is a large stove with a large heating ability of over 2,000 square feet. 

Capacity

With a capacity of over 80 -pound,s this stove will stay burning for longer than the Whitfield pellet stove. 

Efficiency 

The Pleasant Hearth has the highest efficiency rating of any stove on this list. 

Features

The features on this stove are minimal. This could be a positive or negative depending on your tastes. 

Pros

  • Large heating ability
  • Largest-in-class pellet capacity
  • Very efficient
  • Good value for the price

Cons

  • Very plain aesthetic
  • Few control options
  • Could be too powerful for some spaces

Comparison

Product

Description

Rating

Check online

Whitfield Advantage II-T Pellet Stove
  • Excellent features   
  • User-friendly
  • Lots of heating capacity
  • Very efficient
Harman P68 Pellet Stove
  • Sleek design 
  • High capacity
  • Excellent heating power
  • Very efficient 

Castle Pellet Stoves 12327 Serenity Wood Pellet Stove with Smart Controller, 18-1/4'W x 34' H x 23-3/4'D, Black

  • Excellent value
  • Highly programmable
  • Good efficiency
  • Small footprint

Pleasant Hearth 35,000 BTU Medium Pellet Stove

  • Large heating ability
  • Largest-in-class pellet capacity
  • Very efficient 
  • Good value for the price

Conclusion

The Whitfield pellet stove hits all the bases for someone needing a simple, easy-to-use heat source. It's not the biggest, fanciest, or most powerful stove on our list but it excels in a few key ways. The controls on this stove are second to none and make it simple to dial in predictable settings that will keep a room warm and comfortable. The high capacity pellet hopper will also keep this stove running for many hours without repeated trips to the garage to haul in extra pellet bags

The major downside of a Whitfield pellet stove is the fact that the brand is not currently active. These stoves are still widely available new, used, and refurbished but they no longer have the trusted backing of a company ready to take your questions at any time. That said, Whitfield is one of the pioneering companies in the pellet stove industry, and their products are revered for their quality.

Prices on Whitfield stove fell drastically after they merged with Lennox and then dissolved as a brand. This means that there are some excellent deals out there on premium quality stoves. Due to their prominence in the marketplace, it's also easy to find replacement parts and service technicians who are capable of working with your Whitfield pellet stove. Their dissolution as a brand creates a great opportunity for a deal, but there are clear sacrifices when investing in a discontinued product.

The Bottom Line: Due to the Whitfield's status as a company our top choice is the Pleasant Hearth Large 50000 BTU pellet stove. This is a big stove and might be too large for some spaces. For the size, heating ability, pellet capacity, and price though it's hard to beat this pellet stove. The beauty of going bigger rather than smaller is that you can always run your pellet stove at cooler setting. This stove will allow you to do that but then also bring some serious heat when you need it. For the price, we think this is a simple and powerful stove that is worth a serious look if you're in the market for a Whitfield pellet stove.

  • Updated January 10, 2019
  • Stove
Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments

Leave a Reply: