Old Smokey Electric Smoker Reviews 2020 - HVACify

Old Smokey Electric Smoker Reviews

Adding a smoker to your outdoor supply of cooking equipment can certainly overwhelm the average backyard BBQ chef. The options seem endless, and the prices can fluctuate greatly depending on the brand and features. For anyone new to smoking meats and vegetables, you might want to start simple, but you also do not want to sacrifice quality for simplicity. A smoker worth looking into is the Old Smokey Electric Smoker. The Old Smokey brand is well-known, and for good reason. For decades, they have produced a simple yet affordable smoker that yields delicious results.

What Is an Old Smokey Electric Smoker?

The Old Smokey Electric Smoker has longevity. Since 1953, the Old Smokey Electric Smoker has provided customers with a simple interface and delicious results for just around $130 to $160.

Product Specs  

The Old Smokey Electric Smoker comes with a top and bottom grill, chip tray, drop pan, grease absorbing granules, lid hanging cup, and instruction book.

One of the Old Smokey Electric Smoker's unique qualities is that it is comprised of aluminized steel. This, along with the 1250W heating element, gives you the opportunity to effectively control the temperature. While the Old Smokey Electric Smoker does not include a digital control panel, it does have a responsive dial that is simple to use.

Old Smokey Electric Smoker

Image from Amazon

The manufacturer added a reliable heat thermostat to the model to assist you in smoking a variety of meats and vegetables. Like many other contemporary smokers, once you set the temperature and add the wood chips to the wood chip tray, you are done. The chip tray seals to trap the smoky flavor you want. If using scented wood chips, like cherry, hickory, or mesquite, appeals to you, the Old Smokey Electric Smoker is a great fit. The Old Smokey Electric Smoker also controls the internal temperature through a series of sensors.

When we say you are done after the initial set up, we mean it. The Old Smokey Electric Smoker requires no water. In fact, it relies on the juices and moisture of whatever you are cooking to keep producing smoke. This means no checking a timer, no measuring water, and no additional steps.

Externally, the Old Smokey Electric Smoker comes equipped with fireproof, heat-resistant handles. Regardless of how long the smoker has been on, you can rest assured that you can handle its sides and lid safely.

The Old Smokey Electric Smoker's stainless steel bottom cooking grate has lift handles for you to set it exactly where you need it. When you are done cooking, a simple mixture of warm water and soap will clean it. The unit includes two removable grills, which also have handles. The upper grill measures 14.5" and the lower grill measures 12.5".

Internally, it has two adjustable and removable grill levels: an upper measuring 14.5" and a lower measuring 12.5", but it also includes additional food storage racks. The simplicity in design enhances the Old Smokey Electric Smoker's portability, especially with its 23-pound weight.

It is no secret that hours of heat and smoke can make clean up messy with grease and grime. But with the Old Smokey Electric Smoker, you do not need special chemicals for a deep clean. In fact, you can use a pressure washer or add a combination of water and either lemon or vinegar to the drip pan. Start the smoker and wait for the humidity to build. Once you notice condensation, turn off the smoker and clean it with gloves or a wire brush. Any built-up grease or grime should wipe right off.

One of the first things you will notice about your new Old Smokey Electric Smoker is how little assembly it requires. Within minutes, you will be ready to plug in your smoker, add the wood chips, and start smoking delicious chicken wings, beef brisket, or some baby back ribs.

If anything goes wrong with your Old Smokey Electric Smoker, the manufacturer backs it with a 1-year warranty, which is pretty standard for outdoor cooking equipment. Old Smokey notes that the warranty covers defective parts or workmanship and any necessary replacement parts but does not cover rust and traditional wear and tear.

Pricing  

When you shop for a smoker, you want a good balance of affordability and performance—and the Old Smokey Electric Smoker delivers on both fronts. At around $130 to $160, it is not only a bargain, but a quality investment that will yield countless delicious meals for you, your family, and your friends.

How It Compares

We picked a few similar products available on the market to see how they compare.     

  • Masterbuilt 20077515 30-Inch Electric Smoker
  • Masterbuilt 20071117 30″ Digital Electric Smoker
  • Char-Broil Deluxe Digital Electric Smoker
Old Smokey Electric Smoker
  • Color: Grey
  • Size: 15.5"w x 15.5"d x 29"h

Ease of Use

Features

Cleaning & Maintenance

Warranty

PROS

  • Lightweight and mobile
  • Easy to start
  • Large smoking space
  • Requires no water
  • Price

CONS

  • Gets hot when in use
  • Difficulty with temperature management
Masterbuilt 20077515 Front Controller Electric Smoker with Window and RF Controller, 30-Inch
  • 730 sq inches of cooking space with 4 chrome-coated racks and 800 watt heating element with full foam insulation
  • Blue led display makes reading temperatures and cooking time in direct sunlight easy

The Masterbuilt  30" Electric Smoker comes in black, stainless, and stainless steel and has 721 square inches of cooking area, right up there with the Char-Broil Deluxe Digital Electric Smoker on our list. If you regularly host large groups of friends or family or just love to cook, this may be the perfect fit for you.

Like some of the others we reviewed, the Masterbuilt  30" Electric Smoker comes with four adjustable and removable chrome-coated cooking racks. According to Masterbuilt, the area and available cooking racks can smoke up to twelve whole chickens, four racks of ribs, or four pork butts. The wood chip loading tray on the side ensures you never have to open the door and lose the heat when replenishing your wood chips.

Another great internal feature is the inside insulation that maintains a consistent temperature. Masterbuilt makes clean up easy with the removable racks, drip deflector, and front-access drip pan. Even cleaning the inside of the smoker is easy. A simple mixture of hot water and apple cider vinegar should do the trick.

The LED digital control panel provides peace of mind throughout the cooking process, especially with its internal thermometer. When programming the smoker, you only need to set cook time and temperature. This truly takes away the intimidation factor for those new to smoking meats and vegetables.

The Masterbuilt  30" Electric Smoker requires minimal assembly, mainly with the side handles and feet, but the set up is quite easy. The instructions are concise, allowing you to assemble quickly. Once you're done, you can wheel your new smoker to wherever you plan to use it.

The Masterbuilt  30" Electric Smoker includes a 90-day warranty, which is significantly lower than some of its competitors, so keep that in mind in the early days of using it. You can buy this model off Amazon for around $250 to $300, which isn't bad. If you want to spend a few more dollars, you could buy the 40" version with additional features.

Ease of Use

Features

Cleaning & Maintenance

Warranty

PROS

  • Digital controls with LED display
  • Removable and adjustable cooking racks
  • Large cooking area

CONS

  • Price
  • Limited warranty

No products found.

No products found.

The Masterbuilt brand is renowned for its quality and durability. This 30-inch electric smoker lives up to the Masterbuilt name. This model is one of the highest-selling and highest-reviewed on Amazon, and it's easy to see why. It includes four cooking racks, which are coated in chrome to make clean up less messy. The racks are also adjustable, so whether you have a whole turkey, a few briskets, or numerous racks of ribs, the Masterbuilt 30" Digital Electric Smoker can accommodate.

As far as the smoking process goes, Masterbuilt makes it easy. The wood chip tray allows you to add more wood to the smoker without ever opening the door. As we know, uninterrupted, consistent heat is what truly makes smoked foods delicious. The fully insulated interior lends itself to a well-maintained internal temperature.

You can use the digital control panel to set your desired temperature up to 275 degrees F, which is a little less than some of Masterbuilt's rivals. Once everything is ready to go, you can monitor your settings with the blue LED display. The simplicity of this smoker makes it appealing for beginners. It has the set-it-and-forget-it type of operation that you might be familiar with if you have ever used a slow cooker. Once you're done, the clean up is minimal: just wipe down the chrome-coated cooking racks and empty out the water pan.

Users on Amazon report no issues assembling the Masterbuilt 30" Digital Electric Smoker. The included instructions were clear and led to home cooks getting up and running within minutes. One of the nice add-ons Masterbuilt offers is a smoker that already includes smoking chips, so you can get right to it after assembly. If anything happens to your smoker, Masterbuilt backs it with a one-year warranty.

You can purchase the Masterbuilt 30" Digital Electric Smoker from Amazon for around $150 to $200, which is quite affordable for a smoker and ideal for a beginner. In fact, we'd argue this is a near steal in terms of value. The digital control system simplifies the entire process, and the four racks give you tremendous flexibility. Sure, it's compact and doesn't have the output for a large gathering, but for you, your family, and a few friends, this is a great starter.

Ease of Use

Features

Cleaning & Maintenance

Warranty

PROS

  • Digital control system
  • Insulated interior
  • Easy assembly
  • One-year warranty
  • Price

CONS

  • Can't accommodate large groups
  • Temperature range less than others
Char-Broil 17202004 Digital Electric Smoker, Deluxe, Silver
  • Insulated, double-wall construction
  • Advanced control panel with easy-read, blue LED display

One of the most impressive aspects of the Char-Broil Deluxe Digital Electric Smoker is its 725 square inches of cooking area. Combine that with a double-wall lining that's heavily insulated, and it's no surprise that this is one of the best smokers out there for beginners. Char-Broil's extra insulation helps maintain a consistent temperature, which is an absolute must for evenly cooked, smoky, juicy meats and vegetables.

In addition to the insulation feature, the Char-Broil Deluxe Digital Electric Smoker comes with four removable and adjustable cooking racks that, along with an 8.5 cup grease tray, cut down on clean up time. The package also includes a food thermometer. Whether or not you choose to use the food thermometer, this Char-Broil model includes a control panel that displays the internal temperature, meaning you don't have to open the door and check an internal thermometer and lose precious heat in the process. With that control panel, you can adjust the temperature thanks to an all-digital control system with blue LED light which you can even read in direct sunlight.

As with any outdoor cooking device, it's important to protect it from the elements. Leaving your smoker uncovered in the rain or snow could damage the digital control system, so you may want to consider investing in a cover.

The Char-Broil Deluxe Digital Electric Smoker includes a latch that locks quite securely, sealing in the rich, smoky flavor you want to impart on your food. If you still want to actually see the progress of the smoking process, you're in luck because the Char-Broil Deluxe Digital Electric Smoker includes a large glass door. The smoke box that's included has a rather large capacity and can last for up to seven hours, giving you one less thing to monitor.

To top off this entire package, the Char-Broil Deluxe Digital Electric Smoker comes with a one-year warranty from Char-Broil. If you're looking to pick up one of these smokers, you can get one from Amazon's online warehouse for about $280 or through third-party retailers on Amazon for just over $300. It might sound expensive, but remember that this model includes several features you'd normally find in professional high-end smokers but without the added complications. That alone makes this a worthwhile investment, especially for a beginner.

Ease of Use

Features

Cleaning & Maintenance

Warranty

PROS

  • Heavily insulated
  • Digital control
  • Four adjustable and removable racks
  • One-year warranty

CONS

  • Price
  • Can get damaged if not covered

Conclusion

The Old Smokey Electric Smoker blends vintage and modern. It is reliable and delivers consistently good smoked foods. It supports 1250W of heating power in its aluminized frame. With a lid that seals shut, no heat escapes ensuring evenly cooked food with the rich smoky flavor you want. At under $150, it delivers unparalleled value and the same delicious, smoky foods that smokers twice as expensive do.

If you want to expand your outdoor cooking options and invest in a smoker that is not complicated and gets the result you want, the Old Smokey Electric Smoker is the ideal model for you.

Overall: 4/5 Stars

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments

Leave a Reply: